Bkubu,
More weight is a good thing ONLY when there is a hard base below the soft stuff, and its within reach of your tires. That wasn't the case for me in this situation! [^]
As far as the deuce taking on mud that deep, well, it didn't. But the winch was great. I really should have used a snatch block, but there wasn't enough cable to make a round trip to the tree. I swear that left front wheel felt like it was coming off the ground when it was winching out. I put everything (t/case, trans, transfer case) in LOW, eased out the clutch, and it crept up and out. For awhile I was sweating the up part of that! The motor started lumbering a bit at idle, so I slightly squeezed just a little throttle in it. Yeah I know they say use the dash throttle to avoid sudden changes in rpm, but I felt I could do it more smoothly with my foot, and could get off the throttle quickly if something went wrong.
This was actually the 2nd time I got stuck in the same spot. The first time was going the other direction. Another deuce was with on that trip, so he just used a snatch strap to pull me out. Of course I had to try it again coming back through from the other direction.
The Mog in the pic below was unstoppable in the mud! He would drive through a mud hole at a lesiurely pace, stop (sometimes in the middle of it), then back up through it, then go forward through it again just to erase any doubts someone might have of it being able to make it.
No one could make it up the sandy hill, though.