• Steel Soldiers now has a few new forums, read more about it at: New Munitions Forums!

  • Microsoft MSN, Live, Hotmail, Outlook email users may not be receiving emails. We are working to resolve this issue. Please add support@steelsoldiers.com to your trusted contacts.

Can't drain fuel/water separator - Cat 3116

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
I attempted to drain the fuel/water separator on my M35A3. I opened the valve and nothing came out. Looking at the fuel/water separator, nothing sticks out to me that would function as a vent button or anything to release any vacuum on the separator. I ran a small allen wrench through the open valve thinking there was gunk stuck in there, but nothing dripped out. However, there appeared to be either oil or diesel on my wrench as I pulled it out.

The operator's manual makes it seem like you just open the valve and what ever is in the separator drains, be it water, diesel, or both. Is it really supposed to be that simple, or am I missing something? Or do I need to replace the valve on the separator?
 

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
No, the A3s didn't come with an in-tank fuel pump. I'm wondering if I should try to carefully drain the separator while it's running.

Any FMTV guys know? I know the same motor was used in some LMTVs.
 
No, the A3s didn't come with an in-tank fuel pump. I'm wondering if I should try to carefully drain the separator while it's running.

Any FMTV guys know? I know the same motor was used in some LMTVs.
Yes, I drain mine while running. I have a length of hose attached so I can set a coffee can on the ground and open the valve.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HDN

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
I finally got around to draining the fuel-water separator on the truck. I did it while it was running, so I chocked the wheels and donned safety glasses and ear plugs. I got under the truck, opened the drain and out came diesel! So it looks like my fuel system is pretty water-free.

When I did this with the truck running, I was expecting diesel to just spray into my funnel in a steady, high-pressure stream. Instead it was relatively low flow, but steady. I drained the separator into a plastic orange juice jug via funnel. There was some dirt that came out, but I remember having to clean dirt out of the separator valve discharge port. Either way, it'll get a new fuel filter at some point.
 
Last edited:

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
I drained the fuel/water separator a second time, also with the truck running. The fuel came out in a higher-pressure stream this time. The fuel is still water-free, but there's still dirt coming out. Anyone know if this is because I need a new fuel filter because my current one is dirty, or is this because I'm draining from the bottom of the filter assembly and the dirt the filter is catching is just draining out?
 

Sgt Jiggins

Potato Peeler
Steel Soldiers Supporter
434
206
43
Location
Lynchburg, VA
I just put a 24vdc fuel pump and fuel/water separator right next to the tank - been happy with it thus far. Will certainly check it and the return filter for dirt now that you mention this.
 

Floridianson

Well-known member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
7,409
2,503
113
Location
Interlachen Fl.
I drained the fuel/water separator a second time, also with the truck running. The fuel came out in a higher-pressure stream this time. The fuel is still water-free, but there's still dirt coming out. Anyone know if this is because I need a new fuel filter because my current one is dirty, or is this because I'm draining from the bottom of the filter assembly and the dirt the filter is catching is just draining out?
I do not know why you are doing it with the engine running that filter is under suction. If you question anything just change your filters and clean out water trap of any crud. Racor has a 24 volt filter housing with built in electric pump. Just power it up and prime the whole system.
Had to edit lost my mind the other day.
 
Last edited:

guns1977

Active member
109
26
28
Location
AL
I just put a 24vdc fuel pump and fuel/water separator right next to the tank - been happy with it thus far. Will certainly check it and the return filter for dirt now that you mention this.
For my understanding the return filter or strainer you mention is on the return line on top of the pump returning back to the tank? I want to go thru all the screens/strainers in the system when I change out the fuel filter and chk and clean the water seperator if needed.
Thanks
 

Sgt Jiggins

Potato Peeler
Steel Soldiers Supporter
434
206
43
Location
Lynchburg, VA
For my understanding the return filter or strainer you mention is on the return line on top of the pump returning back to the tank? I want to go thru all the screens/strainers in the system when I change out the fuel filter and chk and clean the water seperator if needed.
Thanks
That's what I've found to be the case with the return line filter, yes.

I don't want to start a holy war with this, but a buddy suggested pulling the screen out of the supply side of the injector pump. He suggested they lead to flow-rate problems. Which makes sense in a way. But if you remove this, filter, filter, filter (eg, put one on supply-side too and ensure your hoses are in good shape). Those injector pumps are not inexpensive.
 

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
I've done a little more research into fuel/water separators that won't drain. Apparently this problem is caused when the wax in diesel fuel congeals and blocks the drain passages. I can see this being an issue for this truck since it sat for a long time without being run. So I think the thing needs to be cleaned out. I read that it can be cleaned with q-tips and carburetor cleaner.

That being said, the manual says to drain the fuel/water separator before removing the fuel filter. Since I can't do that, I'm going to try removing the drain valve and emptying the thing that way. I still might remove the whole assembly to clean it, but I hope I don't have to!
 

Monkeyboyarmy

Well-known member
1,337
194
63
Location
Kingsville,Oh.
Tank to pump, to filter, to back of head, through head and injectors to pressure regulator, back to tank. So it should be pressurized while running.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HDN

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
I finally got around to replacing my fuel filter today. For those of you unfamiliar with the M35A3, here are a couple pictures showing where the fuel filter is, the filter being yellow and toward the rear driver side of the motor, and the fuel/water separator valve being red and accessible under the truck behind the front axle:

20200707_100910.jpg 20200707_093125.jpg

The fuel filter in the picture looks damaged because I was already working at it with a pair of large channel lock pliers.

So here's what I did:

1) I set up my workspace. I anticipated a mess and put a large oil pan under where the fuel filter is mounted, mostly from unscrewing the valve from the bottom of the fuel/water separator.

2) I opened the drain valve on the fuel/water separator. As I expected, nothing would come out, so I started to unscrew it from the fuel/water separator housing. I used an 11/16" wrench to loosen it, wrenching it to the frame one time, then got it off the rest of the way by hand. Once I got it off, diesel fuel just poured out. It made me realize that my oil catch/storage pan was too shallow and fuel was splashing around the surrounding ground, so I got newspaper to help absorb it.

3) Thinking I drained all the fuel out of the filter, I started loosening the filter. Like many have reported with their trucks with spin-on filters, it was on really tight! I tried loosening it by hand, but that didn't work, so I used a large pair of channel lock pliers to get it loose. It took several bites, during which I scraped some paint off the filter and even crushed a portion of the housing. Once I got it loose enough to spin off by hand, even more diesel fuel gushed out from the filter, splashing to the pan below. Even after that, there was still some fuel trapped in the filter, and it took some tilting of the filter to get the rest of the fuel out.

Here's the fuel/water separator from the top without the filter:
20200707_101505.jpg

Looking down into an oval hole in the fuel/water separator, I could see there was still diesel fuel in there. I didn't try to flush it out as it looked pretty clean despite the dirt that was blasting out of the valve any time I opened it with the engine running. My guess is that dirt was actually coming from the fuel filter. But I don't have a complete understanding of the flow of fuel through the filter and how the water separator catches the water during engine operation.

4) I prepped the new fuel filter. I bought a Cat 7E-9763 filter as the parts TM specified. I dabbed my rubber-gloved finger in some clean-looking diesel fuel from my catch pan and rubbed it on the filter's o-ring. I also wiped the mating surface of the fuel/water separator clean with a paper towel.

Here's a picture of both filters, the new one being on the left:
20200707_103440.jpg

It's a different filter than what was installed, which was a Cat 1R-1740. My guess is that this is a filter specified for the FMTV, and that it works for this engine too. I'm not sure if the Army put it on or if the auction winner did it. Considering this filter is at least 10 years old, I want to get it cut open to see what its insides look like after all those years!

5) I spun the filter onto the fuel/water separator, using only my hand. The Cat pictograms on the filter show to do it in this fashion. Like a whole-house water filter, it seems you don't have to tighten it like crazy with a tool like the Army or the other guy did. I did tighten it as best as I could, again using only my hand. This will make it easier to get off with a regular spin-on filter wrench the next time I need to change it.

6) I then examined the drain valve I took off earlier. It is a little ball-type valve. In the open position, I couldn't see the sun through it, so it was definitely blocked and probably the source of my no-drain problem. I started with using a 0.5 mm allen wrench to see if I could clear the blockage. The wrench passed through the valve easily, but it wasn't bringing out much with it. I then tried a pipe cleaner meant for my kid's crafting projects, but the bristles were too soft to get anything out :cookoo: So I rolled up a small piece of paper towel and spun it through the valve like a drill bit. And here's the result:

20200707_104915.jpg

That collar that formed on the right end of that piece of paper towel was the gunk causing my blockage! I looked through the valve and was satisfied with how clean it looked inside, so I screwed it back onto the fuel/water separator. I snugged it with a wrench, careful not to make it too tight so as to strip any threads.

7) I started the truck. It ran for a minute with the fuel between the fuel filter and its discharge line. I was surprised it started, but then it died a minute later. To prime the fuel system, I followed the directions in the operator's manual with a little extra care. The manual says to crank at most 15 seconds, and then let the starter motor cool for 30 seconds. Having not received any taxpayer money for the work I've done with my truck, I was a little more careful and cranked the motor for 10-12 seconds at a time, and resting for 30-60 seconds after each cranking session. After about 8 minutes of this process, fuel made it to the motor and the truck roared to life!

8) I checked for leaks at both idle and about 2,000 RPM. Regardless of engine speed, I saw no fuel leakage at the filter or the drain valve :naner:

9) After I shut down the engine and let the truck cool down a little bit, I tested the drain valve. Upon opening the valve, fuel poured out for maybe 3-5 seconds, then stopped. I waited with the valve open to see if more came out, and none did. For kicks, I closed the valve, waited 10 seconds, then re-opened it, and more fuel came out, and in this case and every subsequent try today, it would stream for 3-5 seconds, then pause with a "GLUG GLUG GLUG" sound like air was being purged from somewhere, and more would come out. If the stream really stopped, I would close the valve, wait 10 seconds, then open the valve. The same thing happened.

I'm not sure if this is how the fuel/water separator is actually supposed to work because the operator's manual makes it sound like the fuel should just drain out without much fuss. Perhaps there's more gunk in the fuel/water separator, but I didn't feel like taking it out of the truck today, so that might be a project for the next fuel filter change. That being said, I haven't seen any water come out of the fuel/water separator, and now there's no dirt coming out of it either :)

I hope other truck owners find my documentation helpful. I like how the filter does mount upside down to discourage pre-filling the filter. Just do it by the book and you'll be okay!
 
Last edited:

Sgt Jiggins

Potato Peeler
Steel Soldiers Supporter
434
206
43
Location
Lynchburg, VA
Thank you for writing that up, HDN. I've bypassed all of it on mine, but its good for reference if I ever run into that elsewhere.
 

HDN

Well-known member
2,112
5,088
113
Location
Finger Lakes Region, NY
One more thing I discovered, at least with my truck: The fuel/water separator will drain best right after the motor is shut off. I think this is because there's still enough fuel pressure to force draining. Waiting a longer time will not allow for draining at all.

Make sure to wear a hat and safety glasses when underneath the engine compartment doing the water draining otherwise you might burn the side of your head on the oil pan!

It makes me wonder if there's a bad check valve somewhere in the supply line from the tank, or if air is being bled from the fuel tank cap.
 
Top