• Steel Soldiers now has a few new forums, read more about it at: New Munitions Forums!

  • Microsoft MSN, Live, Hotmail, Outlook email users may not be receiving emails. We are working to resolve this issue. Please add support@steelsoldiers.com to your trusted contacts.

ENDT 673 Mack engine miss diagnosis/repair

AMGeneral

Well-known member
2,301
115
63
Location
Connelly Springs, NC
Well folks, as trouble free as the 673 Mack engine usually is,every now and then you run into one that has troubles,being that Mr Murphy haunts me ALMOST as much as he does Wreckerman,I have 2 with the same problem.


A little engineering info on the Mack that you'll find under the hoods of some M39 series 5 ton trucks......

673 ci displacment inline 6 cylinder turbocharged diesel
211 hp @ 1900 rpm
611 ft/lbs tq @1500 rpm
2 valves per cylinder vs 4 as in the later Mack engines
it uses a American Bosch APE series inline injection pump and Bosch injectors similar to the Multifuel design.

But it differs from the Cat and Cummins engine designs for the cam followers/tappets,the Mack uses a flat tappet design vs a roller as the Cat and Cummins engines.

Herein lies the problem,whether it is caused by the removal of certain friction additives from engine oil over past years or the fact that the tappets themselves only have a face hardening of .005 thickness,irreguardless it tends to wear out cam lobes at a rapid rate.

I actually have diagnosed 2 of my engines to have this same problem,1 just has a small but noticeable miss,the other has a lesser miss,but a much more pronounced hard rap noticable just above the cam at the tappet level on the right side of the engine. Since I already had engine #1 out for fitting in another truck it seemed the best candidate for teardown and repair.

Upon teardown of the engine and measuring of the cam lobe lift,all were within specs except for #3 intake valve,it measured .021 less lift than the other 11,I also noticed that the valve spring for that particular cam lobe was installed upside down,kind of an odd coincidence. This engine shows a rebuild at TEAD in 1975, with bore at STD and rods/mains at .010 oversize bearings,probably the last time it was apart.

I will post pictures and updates as the repairs/ progress,as of now I am ordering a updated cam and tappet set with hardened faces of .013 thickness.
 

Squirt-Truck

Master Chief
Steel Soldiers Supporter
1,180
162
63
Location
Marietta, Georgia
AMGeneral
I can confirm that the reduction in zinc (ZDP component) in the newer oils is taking a severe toll on the older engines with sharp profile cams. The 6602 has the same problem. I will check at work, I believe that I have a listing of oils that still maintain high zinc levels just for this purpose. There are new wear additives that will also correct this, both MB and VW have this requirement for the MB common rail diesel and VW for the PD engines.

Additional hardness depth will only extend the time to failure, not prevent it. Once a chip occurs, it is a self consuming problem.

I know a guy that makes a roller conversion for the 673....:)
 

papabear

GA Mafia Imperial 1SG
13,513
2,420
113
Location
Columbus, Georgia
AMGeneral
I can confirm that the reduction in zinc (ZDP component) in the newer oils is taking a severe toll on the older engines with sharp profile cams. The 6602 has the same problem. I will check at work, I believe that I have a listing of oils that still maintain high zinc levels just for this purpose. There are new wear additives that will also correct this, both MB and VW have this requirement for the MB common rail diesel and VW for the PD engines.

Additional hardness depth will only extend the time to failure, not prevent it. Once a chip occurs, it is a self consuming problem.

I know a guy that makes a roller conversion for the 673....:)
Sounds expensive??
 

Squirt-Truck

Master Chief
Steel Soldiers Supporter
1,180
162
63
Location
Marietta, Georgia
Papabear, its only money...........................
Gee when you drive toys that get 4 MPG who cares.............
(Yea I know I feel the footsteps coming up quickly..)
 

AMGeneral

Well-known member
2,301
115
63
Location
Connelly Springs, NC
roller conversion? Interesting, very interesting,Could you send me more info?

Papabear,being that the cam and tappet kit is $1700+ tax for EACH engine(not counting gaskets,seals or cam bearings) If the roller tappet conversion Mark is talking about is roughly the same price,it would be worth it.
 

papabear

GA Mafia Imperial 1SG
13,513
2,420
113
Location
Columbus, Georgia
roller conversion? Interesting, very interesting,Could you send me more info?

Papabear,being that the cam and tappet kit is $1700+ tax for EACH engine(not counting gaskets,seals or cam bearings) If the roller tappet conversion Mark is talking about is roughly the same price,it would be worth it.
I certainly agree!!:jumpin:
Can I borrow $1650.00?:roll:
 
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website like our supporting vendors. Their ads help keep Steel Soldiers going. Please consider disabling your ad blockers for the site. Thanks!

I've Disabled AdBlock
No Thanks