So, in regards to the original question, basically what I'm hearing is:
- GL sucks because there is a 1 in 4 chance of getting a truck with something seriously wrong with it. I take it when you go to "preview" the trucks at auction you don't get to start them up and run down everyone else on the base
- Private sales suck because you will pay more for a truck that might have the same or more things wrong with it than a GL truck.
What I'm thinking based on this is that I should wait until I have some money saved up, then start looking at trucks. Don't marry the first one I see, oh wait...
Like I said before (I think), I am reasonably close to Fort Drum, so if there were some GL listings there that looked promising I could go check them out, but if you can't verify that the most important components of the vehicle work (engine, tranny, transfer case, diffs), you're still making a gamble. Plus the paperwork is a PITA. I would only consider that route if I could get the truck I want for a
very good price so that the leftovers can be used to potential repairs.
I will definitely take my time and not buy a truck just because I'm impatient. I will definitely wait and get the one I want. This still has to go through my parents, but hopefully I will be more successful that when I tried to convince them to let me get one as a daily driver a few years ago. I know, I'll just tell them I want a motorcycle
first...
GL doesn't suck... you're just taking your chances... I got two deuces for a great price... both are runners but both need work... you will read about guys who bid without previewing and wind up with a little bit of forklift love and a damaged drive shaft or oil pan... you will read about guys who win bids on trucks with a hole in the engine or bad tranny... if you can preview the truck, that is great, but still not a guarantee the truck will make it home 50 miles... my lower radiator hose busted on the drive home... one truck was topless and started spitting out steam from the tranny (clearly i need to remove the water from the tranny)... no gauges on either truck, no parking break on one, no spare tire on one, clutch slipping on one, intermittent headlights on one, the list goes on and on with the repairs ill need to do... however, im fine with that... i bought cheap so i could fix them up at my pace and my budget...
buying private does not have to suck... there are guys out there who flip trucks... they buy from gl, add $1500 to the price and sell it as is... then when you drive 3 hours to see the trucks your told itll be an extra $500 for title... that sucks... there are guys that tear the trucks down and rebuild everything, thats great but you're budget better be 5 times higher than what you posted... then there are also guys out there who will give you a great runner at a fair price... but finding an honest seller can be as much a crap shoot as bidding on gl...
whatever you do, the one thing everyone who has purchased a deuce can agree on is that you better plan for a contingency budget in addition to your purchase price... if its a gl purchase, id say $1k extra in your budget for the unexpected... if you bid on gl then find out the truck is not a runner, figure $4.50 a loaded mile to have it shipped... and before i get flamed by the $1.75 or $2.50 a loaded mile preachers, i just went through this three weeks ago... not only was i getting over $4 a loaded mile, even from eric at hotshots, but in the end i couldnt find a single carrier or broker to move my deuces in the two week time frame gl gave me... i recovered them myself with the help of paulfarber...
if you buy privately, you may not need $1k in budget, but you better still have a fair chunk of change put aside...
i did my gl recovery with my f150 trailing with antifreeze, dot5, gear oil, engine oil, diesel fuel, belts, 1 lower radiator hose, and 30 feet of bulk radiator hose in various sizes for the entire truck... i easily spent $500 on just those materials... regardless of whether you go gl or private, what happens if you break down on the way home? you know how much a wrecker will cost you?
my advice, its free so take it or leave it, would be to shop around for sellers that people here trust... get some prices from those sellers, then follow some bids on gl to see what deuces there sell for... then take that difference in cost between the two and weigh it against the risk of the unknown at gl compared to a safer purchase, but still with no guarantee, from a trusted private seller... add $500 to either price for the unknown... then see where you feel comfortable...
i can recommend ken from kublos surpluss in Brackney, PA... i also discussed buying a deuce with winch from sephirothq (page 1) for a fair price... see if he still has that for sale...
if your parents say no, pm me i can stop by when youre not home with my cbr1000rr and thell them you contacted me through craigs list about buying my bike... ill be sure to brag about the mods i did to get that 440lb 186hp beast up to 200mph...
good luck and welcome to the fever...