• Steel Soldiers now has a few new forums, read more about it at: New Munitions Forums!

  • Microsoft MSN, Live, Hotmail, Outlook email users may not be receiving emails. We are working to resolve this issue. Please add support@steelsoldiers.com to your trusted contacts.

Jury Trial - Code Enforcement

simp5782

Feo, Fuerte y Formal
Supporting Vendor
12,130
9,409
113
Location
Mason, TN
Ok well some of you have to deal with your local code enforcement as in regards to the military hobby or our "junk". This is a spectrum as to how to approach it. Some will state. "No military trucks, equipment, or surplus shall be kept at a personal residence. Military surplus items can not be used by citizens for private use" Pretty broad and retarded. It even means a tent. Well the irritation part that you can cause your local code enforcement and judge is this. File for an appeal to a higher court. In small towns it will be their District or felony court. Same as most big cities. Some may take longer to process thru this step. Time is always on your side.

Most cities and towns have adopted the MUniCode. Municipal code system. It was written by some high class city person who i am sure get bothered by everything. The code for a lot of plates that pertains to military trucks as this "No heavy truck over 8,000lbs shall be stored or maintained at a residence except, consumer vehicles such as duallies, etc." Most of them consider it a commercial vehicle.

Heavy truck is defined as any truck over 8,000lbs by municode.

The loophole is this in the municode. it does not define "Consumer vehicle". The county clerk and other departments may have definitions of consumer vehicles but most do not. All states have a definition of it. Tennessee has it being "anything vehicle or truck owned by a private citizen for their own personal use"

So then once you are thru the lower court and filed your appeal then comes the jump thru the hoops of the appeal court. You do not need to hire an attorney for this. File your appeal and wait. it could be a year, no sense in paying money you do not have to. The other thing is this in circuit court the defendant is suppose to file notices of hearings and what not to get the ball rolling. Unfortunately under the federal law, no person appearing as a defendant in both criminal or civil hearings and litigation is required to initiate the prosecution against them" In other wards you don't have to bring yourself to justice. This is also a time of 12 to 36 months that allows you to keep your things at your home and they can't touch you versus 100 or so a month storage bills. If you paid for an appeal you paid for an appeal bond which bides you all the time from the court, attorney fees, fines, and annoying code enforcement officers.


If you are dealing with a county code issue and the city tries to get involved in its own thing you just tell em that the county has jurisdiction. ESPECIALLY if you have filed an appeal. it then becomes harassing partake if they are aware the matter is already in court. You can't be charged and sent thru the process by a lower jurisdictional court. It can be considered a harmful error to make you look bad to people. Especially on a jury. They just bring up that you have cases in both county and city code. blah blah blah. but should be throw out and disregarded.

My opinion and approach on the whole thing in circuit court at the jury trial is this: Code enforcement says it cant be there cause a "truck that big can't be personal use and its a commercial truck". Or it is over 8000lbs. The exception part is getting the state definition into the peoples minds. since you are being prosecuted by the state at the point and not just the county. The other thing is this. Having a State Trooper, a DOT rep, county clerk, and a department of revenue rep come as witnesses is a good bet. In the state of Tennessee a truck can be 79,000lbs and it can still not be a commercial vehicle. When the trooper, the DOT rep, and the dept of revenue rep all say its personal. and the county clerk how they title the 5 ton in particular as personal. The prosecutor will say that it isnt personal being that big and noone could practically drive that as a personal vehicle or RV or Camper. yet a law enforcement officer, the state department that governs commercial vehicles and tags, and the county clerk who issues the tags says it is personal. The jury is probably not going to understand why they are sitting in court when they do not have to be. Most people don't like nosy people. especially people who like to complain a lot. and everyone has that neighbor that thinks they should mind their own business. That is just human nature. Prosecutors will try to rebuke the officers and peoples statements by their own code but people value the opinion of neutral parties over a defense or prosecutor. In this case the State Employees testifying on the side of a defendant.

It is best to have Have several people testify that their trucks are personal, they can be campers, they can be antiques. Contact as many people as you can close and far to come give their statements. Depositions can be taken anywhere and can be taken anytime and used to help future efforts. Yes they may be complete strangers. But it helps for people to realize that it is a hobby and not just some crazy guy with an army truck in his driveway. This can and does effect all of us as well as people who have had previous problems with their code enforcement as this gives legal effect against the code people.

The issue the county and city has is that the people who complain do it without leaving their number or name. Well when the time comes for court it is just their inspector vs a defendant.

This is my rant and take it how you want but it is how you deal with the system. Take it to court, jump thru the hoops, appeal and go to a jury trial.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Trailboss

Well-known member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
1,577
139
63
Location
Norwood LA
Good luck, Wes. If I was on the jury, I think your arguments would win. Laws should be specific, not ambiguous and open to vague interpretation. I would think case law would support the state's definition.
 

aleigh

Well-known member
1,040
52
48
Location
Phoenix, AZ & Seattle, WA
I would be happy to help you out, give a deposition, whatever. It sounds like you have your bases covered and have a lawyer and everything but a couple thoughts. The first is if you can get statements from your neighbors saying they don't have a problem with it, that might carry more water than random people with trucks. The other thing I would consider is approaching my city councilperson / whatever. I realize that is not going to influence the judge, but, if you can get some good will there you might be able to get the prosecutor to back off. All they have to do is drop or suspend the charges and it just goes away. Maybe take a picture, show the tidy condition in which you store it, claim it's basically just an RV and you're running afoul of a technicality here, military vintage, blah blah. Do you show it at shows or parades? Community goodwill could go a long way here.
 

doghead

4 Star General /Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Steel Soldiers Supporter
26,246
1,179
113
Location
NY
One of the website rules...

• Do not post information regarding past, current or upcoming lawsuits or litigation.
 

simp5782

Feo, Fuerte y Formal
Supporting Vendor
12,130
9,409
113
Location
Mason, TN
One of the website rules...
Modified as opinions.

There are lots of threads discussing code enforcement and DOT ticket issues and what not in which people have discussed their ongoing cases and civil issues.. Those threads need to be modified as well I would think.
 

simp5782

Feo, Fuerte y Formal
Supporting Vendor
12,130
9,409
113
Location
Mason, TN
Good luck, Wes. If I was on the jury, I think your arguments would win. Laws should be specific, not ambiguous and open to vague interpretation. I would think case law would support the state's definition.
Doug,

Last year I had a judge tell me and the attorney i was helping when we pointed out a biased decision in a homicide trial. His response was "Well yes sir that is the law but I don't have to go by that" I was tempted to say well why are we here if we can just make it up as we go.
 

simp5782

Feo, Fuerte y Formal
Supporting Vendor
12,130
9,409
113
Location
Mason, TN
I would be happy to help you out, give a deposition, whatever. It sounds like you have your bases covered and have a lawyer and everything but a couple thoughts. The first is if you can get statements from your neighbors saying they don't have a problem with it, that might carry more water than random people with trucks. The other thing I would consider is approaching my city councilperson / whatever. I realize that is not going to influence the judge, but, if you can get some good will there you might be able to get the prosecutor to back off. All they have to do is drop or suspend the charges and it just goes away. Maybe take a picture, show the tidy condition in which you store it, claim it's basically just an RV and you're running afoul of a technicality here, military vintage, blah blah. Do you show it at shows or parades? Community goodwill could go a long way here.
Under their definition of municode even Profo's LMTV Camper or his 927 camper would not be an exception . I checked into that. since it was not built with the sole purpose of being a camper when it was designed that is not what is is. Pretty vague and gray area. Neighbors are good to be on your side but understanding that its a hobby and not just a crazy guy with an army truck or that your dangerous is the other. You make it seem friendly and that people enjoy these things.
 

USAFSS-ColdWarrior

Chaplain
Super Moderator
Steel Soldiers Supporter
18,550
5,917
113
Location
San Angelo, Tom Green County, Texas USA
For the benefit of almost ALL SS Members who DO NOT possess LAW DEGREES, I'd like to add this official MUNICODE link in the hopes that it helps folks understand just what the "MUNICODE" is....

https://www.municode.com/

In short, it is a standardized municipal code (local law) package to which municipalities (counties, towns, cities, boroughs, townships, etc.) can subscribe and/or adopt as their own without having to have a large Legal Staff on their payrolls. In an attempt by MUNICODE to proliferate an Unified Municipal CODE system, they have themselves opened up their subscriber municipalities to ever-increasing legal challenges as those the OP describes.
 

montaillou

Well-known member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
807
832
93
Location
W.WA
Keep in mind, if you live in a development with HOA (Home Owner's Association) rules, you're SoL if they already prohibit these items. You could always try appealing, but there are plenty of nightmares out there in the news to show how (un)successful this usually is.
 

TNriverjet

Active member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
1,172
24
38
Location
Clifton, TN
Good Lord willing and the creek don’t rise, I’ll never live in an HOA zone.

Wes, we are all rooting for you.

I enjoy the freedoms of relieving myself behind the shed, storing MV parts and the option of parking a big truck in my driveway.
 

Russ Knight

Well-known member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
1,117
1,054
113
Location
Perry, FL
Good Lord willing and the creek don’t rise, I’ll never live in an HOA zone.

Wes, we are all rooting for you.

I enjoy the freedoms of relieving myself behind the shed, storing MV parts and the option of parking a big truck in my driveway.
Behind the shed? How about off the front porch.... Your yard isn't big enough!
 

SCM35A2

Well-known member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
2,072
3,037
113
Location
Florence, SC
Good luck, I'm going to print this out & hold onto it just in case I ever have to deal with any bs like this.
 

Karl kostman

Well-known member
Steel Soldiers Supporter
2,308
893
113
Location
Fargo ND
You know what guys I know its COLD and windy and at times your up to your butt in snow in ND but with that said I NEVER EVER have to deal with anything like this in this state, nobody cares and they just mind their own business!
Karl
 

Reworked LMTV

Expedition Campers Limited, LLC
Supporting Vendor
1,511
1,178
113
Location
TN
Memphis and Detroit. I lived in both. Just can't figure out which City is more corrupt.
 
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website like our supporting vendors. Their ads help keep Steel Soldiers going. Please consider disabling your ad blockers for the site. Thanks!

I've Disabled AdBlock
No Thanks