Howdy Dozer! I honestly can't say exactly, the old gasket looked ok and the pump had no pittting on the gasket face, nor did the end of the block. The only think that seemed out of the ordinary was that the 2 bootom bolts on the retaining ring had a lot of build up on the threads. It seemed odd because it was on part of the threads that were in the block. If I hadn't been 2 hours from nowhere, I probably would have replaced them with new stainless grade 5s also. Instead I rotated the 2 best bolts to the bottom position, wire brushed the threads on the others and put them in the top positions. No leaks after a 30 minute shakeout drive today, but we'll keep and eye on it down the road.
I try to use good hardware for several reasons. You're never buying more than a couple at a time, so a couple bucks extra for stainless is no bigee. But honestly the main reason is, I usually expect to have to do things twice, having clean fastners to work with the second time around eases the aggrivation factor