Steel Soldiers now has a few new forums, read more about it at: New Munitions Forums!
Exactly my thoughts (and MHO) too.cranetruck said:I'm sure you will test your new transmission, and report the findings, especially when the truck is loaded.
I can imagine that you won't be able to use 5th gear much at all when loaded down or at least having to shift down more often. Running empty is not a condition on which to base a redesign IMHO.
All opinions aside, I think you do great work.
I think that torque rating is actually a little high going by the original spicer numbers, from what I've been told. I believe that like everything else they're quite under-rated. Here's an example of the durability of these trannies; my V8 CAT is 225hp and 636 cubic inches. I found where a 3208 Cat (nearly identical engine) of 180hp made in the area of 450 lbs/ft. Mine being another 45hp, I think I could safely say she's around 500 lbs/ft. and online calculators have it at 491 lbs/ft at 2400rpm. Now take that, consider it's now in a truck tipping the scales at a fuzz over 18,000 lbs and this past week did a little towing that gave me a combined weight around 32,000 lbs or more. This was 70 or so miles at around 53-55mph which runs about 2400rpm with 40" NDT's. Most small hills it was able to maintain though larger obviously steeper grades would drop to 45mph then gain back pretty easily at the top.gringeltaube said:Exactly my thoughts (and MHO) too.
Somewhere I found that the deuce tranny is rated to withstand 400 lbs/ft. A std. deuce Multifuel engine develops around 300. But if we need a 5ton Multifuel or any other 465 with the fuel turned up (peak torque at 430) to move a M35A2 at highway speed at (only) 2200 rpm via those extreme o.d. gears the tranny would be operating for longer periods at it's very limit. Something has to give, sooner or later. I mean fatigue....
Like I said earlier, time will tell and it sure will depend a lot on the total weight... (drivers brain and right foot included)
Excellent post. Very informative.BEASTMASTER said:if it ain't broke don't fix it !!!