If it required shims you would hear a god awfull sound not just a click click more like a squeal and clank/ metal screaming sound or it would bind up when engaged . Do you hear the starter spin when it clicks, if not you have a voltage or solenoid type of problem.
It fired and ran good for almost a month!... Then it would go 'pop' but it didn't sound like a full on, 'Im a weak solenoid... or you got weak batteries' pop... I surmised the gears weren't meshing by the sound... but the bendex wasn't protruding enough to start the starter spinning... it seems the shims have fixed it....
uh ETA.... it just went out again after the third start after putting the original shims in (which were ~.10" ! ... I guess I'll take stuff apart and measure now.... never can outsmart that TM!
ETA Days later....
found this thread usefull:
http://www.steelsoldiers.com/cucv/49893-dumb-newbie-starter-question.html it discusses which starters need shims and which don't. I bought a new 28MT starter, but I can' find "no shim" written on it anywhere...
Here are some directions on how to shim found in another starter thread here:
http://macc.chevelles.net/starter.htm
Also to get my bell housing off I had to undo both the trans cooler hard lines... anyways The details that seem to be omitted are exactly how to measure the clearance between the ring gear and the pinion... what I ended up doing:
Found a small piece of wire, bent it into a 90 deg 1.5" 'L' shape, and put my dial caliper on it... it's diameter was .057"... good spec is .02 to .06 so I'm figured I was probably just a bit bigger than that if it slid in between... shimmed until it fit in between ring gear and protruded to the starter's splines without bending or forcing... (need .02 +.04 shim for total of .06")... so took out .04" shim... so I should have just a bit over .02" clearance by just using the .02" shim... which would indicate that I had just over 0 clearance without a shim... I said a prayer and put it all back together. So far one good start.
I understand some shim kits come with a tool like the one I made, but mine didn't have it.
Hope it helps. I'll post here if I have more trouble with this starter.
Tom